Is Trump really like Mussolini? Are people just reacting to the idea the system is broken? Do we need to be worried? http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-return-of-the-1930s-1457396236 The Return of the 1930s Donald Trumps demagoguery may be a foretaste of whats to come. Italian dictator Benito Mussolini saluting during a public address in 1938. ENLARGE Italian dictator Benito Mussolini saluting during a public address in 1938. PHOTO: KEYSTONE/GETTY IMAGES By BRET STEPHENS March 7, 2016 7:17 p.m. ET 1227 COMMENTS In temperament, he was bombastic, inconsistent, shallow and vainglorious. On political questions, he made up his own reality as he went along. Physically, the qualities that stood out were the scowling forehead, the rolling eyes, the pouting mouth. His compulsive exhibitionism was part of his cult of machismo. He spoke in short, strident sentences. Journalists mocked his absurd attitudinizing. Remind you of someone? The description of Benito Mussolini comes from English historian Piers Brendons definitive history of the 1930s, The Dark Valley. So does this mean that Donald Trump is the second coming of Il Duce, or that yesteryears Fascists are todays Trumpkins? Not exactly. But that doesnt mean we should be indifferent to the parallels with the last dark age of Western politics. Among the parallels: The growing belief that democracy is rigged. That charisma matters more than ideas. That strength trumps principles. That coarseness is refreshing, authentic. Also, that immigrants are plundering the economy. That the worlds agonies are someone elses problem. That free trade is a game of winners and losersin which we are the invariable losers. That the rest of the world plays us for suckers. That our current leaders are not who they say they are, or where they say they are from. That they are conspiring against us. These are perennial attitudes in any democracy, but usually marginal ones. They gained strength in the 1920s and 30s because the old liberal order had been shatteredfirst at Gallipoli, Verdun and Caporetto; then with the Bolshevik coup in Russia, hyperinflation in Germany, Black Tuesday in the United States. What are the roots that clutch, what branches grow/Out of this stony rubbish? wondered T.S. Eliot in The Waste Land, in 1922. Mussolinis Blackshirts marched on Rome the same year. Modern Americans have experienced nothing like those shocks, which is one important difference with the 1930s. The French army lost more men on an average day on the Western Front than the U.S. lost in our worst year in Iraq. At the height of the Great Depression, real per capita GDP fell by nearly 30% from its previous peak. At the depth of the 2008-09 recession, it fell by about 6%, and soon recovered. Then again, the pain youre in is the pain you tell yourself youre in. Or, at least, the pain youre told youre in, usually by political doctors who specialize in hyping the misery of others. So were being invaded by Mexicansexcept that for years more Mexicans have been returning home than coming here. So China is destroying our manufacturingexcept industrial employment has surged in recent years, especially in the Rust Belt. So the great mass of Americans are now unprotected from the vagaries of the global economysave for Medicare, ObamaCare, the earned-income tax credit, public-employee pensions and every other entitlement that Mr. Trump promises to protect. All this generates the hysteria, the penchant for histrionic rhetoric, the promise of drastic measures, the disdain for civility, the combination of victimhood and bullying on which the Trump candidacy feeds, and which it fuels. Reading through the avalanche of pro-Trump emails that arrive in my inbox (by now numbering in the thousands), whats notable are the belittling put-downs (youre an $@%&, Bret-boy), the self-importance (I make more money than you) and the sense of injured pride (how dare you call me a vulgarian?). This is precisely the M.O. of their candidate. In breaking the taboos of civility and civilization, a Trump speech and rally resembles the rallies of fascist leaders who pantomimed the wishes of their followers and let them fill in the text, writes the University of Marylands Jeffrey Herf in a brilliant essay in the American Interest. Trump says what they want to say but are afraid to express. In cheering this leader, his supporters feel free to say what they really believe about Mexicans, Muslims, and women. This is not the politics of economic anxiety or dislocation. Its a politics of personal exhibitionism, the right-wing equivalent of refusing to be body-shamed. Thanks to Donald, the Trumpkins at last have a license to be as ugly as they want to be. *** Mr. Trumps bid for the presidency takes place during a period of mediocre but nonetheless unmistakable economic and employment growth in the U.S. But as a wise friend of mine noted the other day, what happens when the next bubble bursts and the next recession arrives? A reasonable person can argue that Donald Trump is more Silvio BerlusconiItalys clownish billionaire and former prime ministerthan he is a new Mussolini. Maybe. Or maybe Mr. Trumps style of politics is just a foretaste of whats to come, especially if an American downturn became a global depression. In the work of preserving civilization, nine-tenths of the job is to understand the past and stress its most obvious lessons. Now would be a good time to re-remember the 30s. Write bstephens@wsj.com.
Mussolini was real at a time when no one thought it could happen. History repeats itself. The first thing Mussolini did was to round up political rivals. If I were a liberal I would seriously be making plans to get the hell out of dodge.
a socialist who silenced apposing speech? that describes bernie supporters better than it does trump.
No buy his neck... I love it when the left starts talking about Mussolini when the only real difference between what they've built here and what mussolini had in Italy is the Name...