View Single Post
  #19 (permalink)  
Old 07-13-2004, 10:59 AM
hankdane's Avatar
hankdane hankdane is offline
Contributor
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: California
Posts: 100
hankdane is on a distinguished road
Credits: 1,201
Default But it is a moral issue...

Quote:
Originally Posted by rwspin";p=&quot View Post
It's not so much a moral issue as a social one... public health really.
I understand the "public health" arguments, but they are essentially utilitarian. I specifically asked for moral justification. The utilitarian arguments have problems as well, but at least I understand them.

If Joe Junkie wants to shoot up in his own basement, that is his problem. I couldn't care less. You want to make it your problem, you can send him a card or volunteer at the local drug prevention center. If you want to send armed men to his house, kick in his door and take him away, you better have a moral justification for it.

It gets worse. You are making it not only your business, your are forcing it on me as well. Through my taxes, I have to pay for your cause. Joe is hurting nobody, the armed men are hurting Joe, and I am forced to subsidize the armed men. What's the moral justification for that?
__________________
None love freedom heartily, but good men; others love not freedom, but license.
- John Milton
Reply With Quote