View Single Post
  #149 (permalink)  
Old 05-08-2008, 06:03 AM
Publius Infinitum's Avatar
Publius Infinitum Publius Infinitum is offline
Banned
Commentator
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,114
Publius Infinitum is a jewel in the roughPublius Infinitum is a jewel in the roughPublius Infinitum is a jewel in the rough
Credits: 10,413
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by BigRed View Post
The fact that I have to point something out in the United States Constitution to you is odd to me. The fact that I have to provide a source is odd to me.

The source has already been provided in this thread. Congress can only declare war. Not the President. That's that.
FAIL!

You intentionally failed to address the issue; thus your argument fails, again (AS USUAL)...

For the edification of the objective third party that may read this thread: The issue was that the USC does NOT declare the method by which Congress shall declare war... That, in fact, Congress did declare war post 9-11 and did so in authorizing the use of military force. Where one sovereign uses military force against another sovereign nation, WAR is the only potential function of that use; thus authorizing the executive to use military force against another sovereign the congress, IN POINT OF FACT: DECLARED WAR.

There is NOTHING in the USC which requires Congress to use any particular language in delcaring war; it does not mandate that the phrase "DECLARE WAR" must be used when congress asserts its authorization.

The member is being intentionally obtuse to protect a failed position and has repeatedly refused to answer the salient question in that failed defense. [/quote]
Reply With Quote