Quote:
Originally Posted by klipkap
Beletesri, you have now twice accused me of having invented Myth 2, namely that one of the main Zionist mantras is that the Palestinians followed the Jews into the disputed southern Levant and cannot therefore claim to have been displaced when the State of Israel was created.
I dont like it when people accuse me of dishonest debate, so I am now throwing down the gauntlet to you. Tell me and the readers of this section of the forum that this is NOT a regular theme in Zionist publications and web sites, and that I have invented it.
Or, if on the other hand, your contention is that indeed such Zionist sources DO frequently make this claim, but that it is NOT a myth, but is the plain truth, then start to show your evidence, instead of vacantly implying that I am lying. I will naturally respond.
So go for it. It it a Zionist mantra or not, and if so, what is your evidence that it is true?
Time to back up your insults.
|
No insults in any posts above..tho you feel such from the thrashing with facts.
Not how Klipkap tries to Slide from the point we were talking about.. the Validity of the creation of Israel.
Now lost by him.
That creation was as/or more valid of any of the former Ottoman lands.
and he has tried to morph it into what? Some vague claimed 'Myth'.
I keep posting hard facts- he wants to push them all into some 'myth' bucket rather than debate any I have given.
The fact is some Arabs were there, some/many certainly followed the Zionists in..
The Population of Both, especially Arabs, increased dramatically (those you claim were displaced!)
But I don't see "Displacement" of any significance (there's always a little in statecraft as there was throughout the former Ottoman lands),
aside from the Displacement that was a Result of the Arab-Started 1948 War, NOT the creation/partition of Israel/Palestine.
Another Truth Klipkap can't make a myth.
Quote:
"I do not want to impugn anybody but only to help the refugees. The fact that there are these refugees is the direct consequence of the action of the Arab States in opposing Partition and the Jewish State. The Arab States agreed upon this policy unanimously and they must share in the solution of the problem,
- Emil Ghoury, Secretary of the Arab Higher Committee, the official leadership of the Palestinian Arabs, in the Beirut newspaper, Daily Telegraph, September 6, 1948
|
"Taken", "Bought", "annexed", "Sovereignty"...
all self-contradicted and/or Lost by klipkap on this page alone!.. now on to... "Displaced". And deluded/obsessive reference to 'Myths'.
LOL