Quote:
Originally Posted by i.beletesri
You continue to post the most UNjewish credentials I've ever seen.
|
I must be a race traitor because I posted an article by Yehoshua porath, arguably the most respected Jewish demographer of all time. Ok, this is why i pretty much ignore everything you write.
Quote:
and 3, now, quoting a 22 yr old article by Porath, a Leftist Anti-Israeler from the at least as left/anti-Israel NY Rev of books (who has a small stable full of anti-Israelers), Arguing Against Joan Peters' Book which supports the Premise of Arab population growth through emmigration. The book itself which you DON'T even mention, but in that Porath is making a weak rebuttal against it, which in turn is later re-rebutted by Daniel Pipes.
|
Peters is a fraud, that is accepted by allcomers except maybe a deluded, dreaming few. Here however Porath explains why her arguments which you so shamelessly regurgitate, amount to nothing less than bs.
Quote:
|
Alan Dershowitz recent book, 'The Case for Israel' uses Peters', now Time-Tested facts so heavily, he was accused of Plagiarism in text and Idea- taking whole portions.
|
if by'time tested' you mean sheer made up disingenuity, then yah. Feel free to consume at your leisure. Just the most venerated demographers in Israel don't agree with you or dershowitz.
Quote:
|
You mention your "Jewishness".. but Please.. debate as you will, there is Nothing pro-Jewish in your posts....not even 'half'.
|
I'm not dropping my pants to show you proof.
*EDIT*
hmm, the race-traitor argument again. So far you've tried to refute my post by saying that I'm anti-semite, not jewish, maybe am jewish but not jewish enough, maybe am jewish but am a traitor because I don't support the bs fallacies that keep getting passed off as truth regarding demograpphics.
I must be a leftist, and that's bad, even though it was leftists who founded Israel, but wait that's good.
you sound conflicted and angry, but nowhere do you ever make any decent arguments. In fact I can respect a good argument for any facet of the debate but with you I just find barren soil.
I have one MO. Tell it like it is, take the good with the bad and accept truth wherever it leads you. Don't (*)(*)(*)(*) on my back and tell me it's raining. The only way to resolve a situation is to expose a situation and lay it bare.
You will notice porath's piece makes great comment about about Arab propaganda. A good debater would have read it and taken that tack.
As for Israel being a client state, that's a given. I don't know why you pretend otherwise. Israel has been client to britain france and the US. That's called alliance and the seat of strategic thinking. You make it sound like a bad thing for me to say it out loud.