Political Forum
     

Go Back   Political Forum > Political Issues > Other Political Issues > Education


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 07-26-2004, 09:54 AM
mpotter mpotter is offline
Commentator
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 1,145
mpotter is on a distinguished road
Credits: 9,983
Default College Tuition Hikes

I don't know about you, but I feel this is a huge issue right now. If any of you out there plan on having kids or have kids getting ready for college, this should be a huge issue for you as well. College tuition since Bush entered office, has gone UP by 35%!!! Bush is not doing a (*)(*)(*)(*) thing about it.

Quote:
College Opportunity For All (http://www.johnkerry.com)

In America, every young person who works hard ought to have the chance to go to college. Making college affordable is about America's promise - that all people should have the chance to make the most of their abilities. It's also about America's future, since our ability to compete in the economy of tomorrow depends on our ability to secure skills and training today.

Today, we're not realizing that vision. In the last three years, tuitions have risen by 35 percent, and as a result, some 220,000 young people have been priced out of college. At the same time, many students don't go to college because they just don't think it's realistic for them.

We can do better. John Kerry and John Edwards have a comprehensive plan to expand college opportunity. They will:

Offer a College Opportunity Tax Credit on up to $4000 of tuition for four years of college. This credit will be fully available to families having trouble with the costs of college and to young people who are paying their way through school. And John Kerry will work with colleges to provide the benefits of the credit at the beginning of each school year, when students need it most.

Simplify the Student Aid Application Process. Today, there are more questions on an application for a $5,000 student loan than on an application for a $2 million small business loan. John Kerry will simplify the student aid application, allow many students to apply for college on a postcard, and make sure students can get information about college earlier in the application process.

Help More Young People Climb the Ladder to College. For many young people, college is a distant dream. John Kerry and John Edwards believe we should reach out to young people and show them the path to college. Through initiatives like GEAR UP, John Kerry will expand tutoring, mentoring, and college preparation classes, and he will also help more young people negotiate the college application process.

Help More Young People Finish College. Only about one half of Americans who go to college actually graduate. John Kerry will work with high schools and colleges to boost college completion. This means strengthening the high school curriculum, so that more students arrive at college with the skills to succeed. It also means giving parents more information about schools' graduation rates, and rewarding colleges that do an especially good job at ensuring that their students graduate.

Offer National Service Opportunities. John Kerry will make a new deal with hundreds of thousands of young people: If you will serve America for two years-working in a school, a health center, or strengthening America's security-we will make sure you can attend four years of college tuition-free.
[/quote]
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Red Cross - Donate Today    Save the Rainforest
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 07-26-2004, 11:18 AM
Liberty's Avatar
Liberty Liberty is offline
Site Moderator
Guru
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Georgia
Posts: 4,594
usa us georgia
Liberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud of
Credits: 23,208
Default Quick thoughts - agree or disagree?

Quote:
In America, every young person who works hard ought to have the chance to go to college.
Not true. I've know plenty of people who were very hard workers that didn't have the brain power to complete high school, much less attend college. For those who are hard working and have at least average intelligence, college should be available, and already is.

Quote:
Today, we're not realizing that vision. In the last three years, tuitions have risen by 35 percent, and as a result, some 220,000 young people have been priced out of college.
It's not our "vision to realize" -- it's the student's. The major barrier to a college education is not the cost, it's how hard students are willing work to get in to a college and do well once they're there. I'd love to see where they came up with the 220,000 number of students "priced out" of college. I've never once met someone who really wanted to go to college, but didn't because it was too expensive.

Quote:
Offer a College Opportunity Tax Credit on up to $4000 of tuition for four years of college. This credit will be fully available to families having trouble with the costs of college and to young people who are paying their way through school. And John Kerry will work with colleges to provide the benefits of the credit at the beginning of each school year, when students need it most.
This will surely ease the burden of a college education costs for people that can already afford college. Since it's a tax credit, it won't do much for low income families that already don't pay any taxes. It also won't do anything to address the problem of students dropping out of school. I also don't like the way this is worded... hopefully the $4,000 would have to spread out over 4 years.

Quote:
Simplify the Student Aid Application Process. Today, there are more questions on an application for a $5,000 student loan than on an application for a $2 million small business loan.
This would be great (as long as the new form was as accurate at determining the level of need as the old).

Quote:
John Kerry will allow many students to apply for college on a postcard
Isn't it up to the university how they want to take applications? Do they really need John Kerry to "allow" it? LOL.

Quote:
John Kerry will make sure students can get information about college earlier in the application process.
Yes, because many of us know potential college students that never ended up going because they did not get information early enough. ROFL.

Quote:
Help More Young People Climb the Ladder to College. For many young people, college is a distant dream. John Kerry and John Edwards believe we should reach out to young people and show them the path to college. Through initiatives like GEAR UP, John Kerry will expand tutoring, mentoring, and college preparation classes, and he will also help more young people negotiate the college application process.
I hate to be negative, but the students that see college as a "distant dream" are not going to be the ones who seek tutoring, mentoring, and college prep classes. That is, there aren't millions of students out there who feel like they can't make it into college because they can't find a tutor or college prep class. I'm not saying tutoring doesn't help students, just that it's not going to help many students attend college who otherwise would not.

Quote:
Help More Young People Finish College. Only about one half of Americans who go to college actually graduate. John Kerry will work with high schools and colleges to boost college completion. This means strengthening the high school curriculum, so that more students arrive at college with the skills to succeed.
It's good that he says he wants to boost the high school curriculum, but that doesn't mean that students are going to work any harder. There is only so much a school can do. Beyond a certain point, it's really up to the student (and parents to help instill a work ethic).[/quote]

Quote:
rewarding colleges that do an especially good job at ensuring that their students graduate.
This is an unbelievably stupid idea. The goal is to get an education, not to simply "finish college." There are already too many schools pressured into grading easily - do we also need government bribes to pass students? This measure would do nothing but reduce the overall quality of graduates.

Quote:
Offer National Service Opportunities. John Kerry will make a new deal with hundreds of thousands of young people: If you will serve America for two years-working in a school, a health center, or strengthening America's security-we will make sure you can attend four years of college tuition-free.
My intitial (and probably naive) reaction to this is, what will it do to the size and preparedness of our military? Many people join to serve their country and get a free college education. If this can be accomplished through working at a school or health center (doing who knows what) in two years, then why join the military? Do we want to "strengthen America's security" with kids that are in and out in two years? Is that a good investment for the amount of time and money spent training them? How much will this plan cost the average taxpayer?
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 07-26-2004, 12:05 PM
mpotter mpotter is offline
Commentator
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 1,145
mpotter is on a distinguished road
Credits: 9,983
Default .

Quote:
In America, every young person who works hard ought to have the chance to go to college.
Quote:
Not true. I've know plenty of people who were very hard workers that didn't have the brain power to complete high school, much less attend college. For those who are hard working and have at least average intelligence, college should be available, and already is.
You are hanging with the wrong crowd...take a step off the shortbus because there are plenty of people out there who get B's in high school and don't get scholarships to go to college and have parents who make just a little too much money for them to get financial aid, thus the student can't afford college.


Quote:
Today, we're not realizing that vision. In the last three years, tuitions have risen by 35 percent, and as a result, some 220,000 young people have been priced out of college.
Quote:
It's not our "vision to realize" -- it's the student's. The major barrier to a college education is not the cost, it's how hard students are willing work to get in to a college and do well once they're there. I'd love to see where they came up with the 220,000 number of students "priced out" of college. I've never once met someone who really wanted to go to college, but didn't because it was too expensive.
You obviously don't have any children or don't plan on having any children because if you did, you would understand that it is our vision to realize. I know plenty of people who decided to work instead of going to college to try and save money for it and were never able to go because they can't save on high school derived jobs. If you can't pay up front, you are screwed. Not all of us are able to have mommy and daddy pay for everything for us.

Quote:
Offer a College Opportunity Tax Credit on up to $4000 of tuition for four years of college. This credit will be fully available to families having trouble with the costs of college and to young people who are paying their way through school. And John Kerry will work with colleges to provide the benefits of the credit at the beginning of each school year, when students need it most.
Quote:
This will surely ease the burden of a college education costs for people that can already afford college. Since it's a tax credit, it won't do much for low income families that already don't pay any taxes. It also won't do anything to address the problem of students dropping out of school. I also don't like the way this is worded... hopefully the $4,000 would have to spread out over 4 years.
Any little bit helps...

Quote:
Simplify the Student Aid Application Process. Today, there are more questions on an application for a $5,000 student loan than on an application for a $2 million small business loan.
Quote:
This would be great (as long as the new form was as accurate at determining the level of need as the old).
"Need" is hard to define...colleges are too strict on this

Quote:
John Kerry will allow many students to apply for college on a postcard
Quote:
Isn't it up to the university how they want to take applications? Do they really need John Kerry to "allow" it? LOL.
I believe he is talking about state colleges, not private institutions.

Quote:
John Kerry will make sure students can get information about college earlier in the application process.
Quote:
Yes, because many of us know potential college students that never ended up going because they did not get information early enough. ROFL.
Ever heard of rushing to visit colleges in your last year of high school because you didn't get a response back until the last minute?

Quote:
Help More Young People Climb the Ladder to College. For many young people, college is a distant dream. John Kerry and John Edwards believe we should reach out to young people and show them the path to college. Through initiatives like GEAR UP, John Kerry will expand tutoring, mentoring, and college preparation classes, and he will also help more young people negotiate the college application process.
Quote:
I hate to be negative, but the students that see college as a "distant dream" are not going to be the ones who seek tutoring, mentoring, and college prep classes. That is, there aren't millions of students out there who feel like they can't make it into college because they can't find a tutor or college prep class. I'm not saying tutoring doesn't help students, just that it's not going to help many students attend college who otherwise would not.
Again you must not have any children or plan on having any because it is our duty to them to try and help them realize how important college is, and to give them all the resources we can to help them achieve that goal. We can't let kids simply rot on the streets because they had a poor sense of self esteem.

Quote:
Help More Young People Finish College. Only about one half of Americans who go to college actually graduate. John Kerry will work with high schools and colleges to boost college completion. This means strengthening the high school curriculum, so that more students arrive at college with the skills to succeed.
Quote:
It's good that he says he wants to boost the high school curriculum, but that doesn't mean that students are going to work any harder. There is only so much a school can do. Beyond a certain point, it's really up to the student (and parents to help instill a work ethic).
You are right, but why not give them the benefit of the doubt. You are a strong pescimist

Quote:
rewarding colleges that do an especially good job at ensuring that their students graduate.
Quote:
This is an unbelievably stupid idea. The goal is to get an education, not to simply "finish college." There are already too many schools pressured into grading easily - do we also need government bribes to pass students? This measure would do nothing but reduce the overall quality of graduates.
Again with the pescimism...you automatically think that this is the only solution to helping students graduate. Why is it not possible to increase quality of education and teachers to help increase the numbers?

Quote:
Offer National Service Opportunities. John Kerry will make a new deal with hundreds of thousands of young people: If you will serve America for two years-working in a school, a health center, or strengthening America's security-we will make sure you can attend four years of college tuition-free.
Quote:
My intitial (and probably naive) reaction to this is, what will it do to the size and preparedness of our military? Many people join to serve their country and get a free college education. If this can be accomplished through working at a school or health center (doing who knows what) in two years, then why join the military? Do we want to "strengthen America's security" with kids that are in and out in two years? Is that a good investment for the amount of time and money spent training them? How much will this plan cost the average taxpayer?
You hate Americas youth don't you? You see, not all of us want our children going to war to risk their lives so they can pay for college. If a kid wants to defend this country and protect the people of our nation, that is one thing, but I don't want someone over in Iraq getting killed because he/she was trying to pay for college. Yes why join the millitary if you have other options. That is such a republican thing to say. Again I ask that you exit the short bus for a minute and try and think about what you are asking our youth to do. "Risk your life so you can go to college, its your only option"
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 07-26-2004, 01:51 PM
Liberty's Avatar
Liberty Liberty is offline
Site Moderator
Guru
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Georgia
Posts: 4,594
usa us georgia
Liberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud ofLiberty has much to be proud of
Credits: 23,208
Default .

Quote:
Originally Posted by mpotter";p=&quot View Post
You are hanging with the wrong crowd...take a step off the shortbus because there are plenty of people out there who get B's in high school and don't get scholarships to go to college and have parents who make just a little too much money for them to get financial aid, thus the student can't afford college.
Actually this was "my crowd." My parents made too much money for me to get financial assistance (which means GRANTS -- students always qualify for loans)-- but I was still able to go to college. Here's the secret : GET A JOB! It's a really good program. They ask you to complete simple tasks and then give you money in return! Doesn't it sound silly to force someone else's parents to pay for my school simply because my parents preferred to buy new cars for themselves rather than pay my for my college?

Quote:
Any little bit helps...
ROFL -- let's get this straight. You're advocating a policy that purports to help people that can't afford college by giving TAX BREAKS. Hmm, this should help all who pay taxes and are supporting a student in college... in other words, it helps everyone BUT the poor -- oh, i forgot --- for them, "every little bit helps."

Sickening. If you really want to help poor people afford and get into college, can't you think of at least a dozen ways to do it better than this?

Quote:
I believe he is talking about state colleges, not private institutions.
Yeah, and...? Does the POTS has any more authority over the application process at state universities than he does over private universties?

Quote:
Quote:
John Kerry will make sure students can get information about college earlier in the application process.
Ever heard of rushing to visit colleges in your last year of high school because you didn't get a response back until the last minute?
Nope. I believe most students visit colleges BEFORE they apply. But who cares? "Getting information about college earlier in the application process" will do absolutely nothing to ameliorate the situation you describe.

Quote:
Again you must not have any children or plan on having any because it is our duty to them to try and help them realize how important college is, and to give them all the resources we can to help them achieve that goal. We can't let kids simply rot on the streets because they had a poor sense of self esteem.
Sorry, but you aren't going to raise self-esteem and engender educational values by offering more funding to tutoring and mentoring programs. Kids are not going to "rot on the streets" because they didn't have a math tutor in the 10th grade. Learning to value an education comes from good parenting, not a tax funded after-school program.

Quote:
You are right, but why not give them the benefit of the doubt. You are a strong pescimist
I prefer "Realist." Most students aren't learning the current curriculum. Expanding the curriculum will be good for those who want to learn but do little for those who don't.

Quote:
Why is it not possible to increase quality of education and teachers to help increase the numbers?
Sorry, but you're being naive. Having worked in academics, professors are plenty able (and very willing) to "increase the quality of education," the problem is that students are not willing to work as hard as they once were. Professors are constantly under pressure not to make things too difficult. I believe students do not have a right to a college education. They should have a right for the opportunity, but the education itself needs to be earned through hard work.

Quote:
You hate Americas youth don't you? You see, not all of us want our children going to war to risk their lives so they can pay for college. If a kid wants to defend this country and protect the people of our nation, that is one thing, but I don't want someone over in Iraq getting killed because he/she was trying to pay for college. Yes why join the millitary if you have other options. That is such a republican thing to say. Again I ask that you exit the short bus for a minute and try and think about what you are asking our youth to do. "Risk your life so you can go to college, its your only option"
Hmm, I guess they don't teach reading comprehension skills in school anymore, either. Where did I ask anyone to "risk your life so you can go to college, its you only option." I merely stated that Kerry's policy might have an impact on the military.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 08-06-2004, 03:14 PM
xantar's Avatar
xantar xantar is offline
Observer
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Texas
Posts: 12
xantar is on a distinguished road
Credits: 337
Send a message via ICQ to xantar Send a message via AIM to xantar Send a message via MSN to xantar Send a message via Yahoo to xantar
Default College is a risky investment

The other problem is that becuase of the horrible economy, having a college degree is no longer an asset, but a liability.

Unless you come froma wealthy family, the 4 years you will spend in college are a risky investment. You have to work to pay your tution at a minimum wage job or lower, you get braodsided by so many fees and expenses, you run up a huge credit card debt, and when you get out, there is still no garuntee that you will be getting a job better than what you had before you left for college.

I know plenty of people with Engineering Degree who are sacking groceries and delivering pizzas. Of course, the rich kids are living off of mom and dad while they go to grad school or gota cushy job orking for daddy or one of his friends.
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 08-06-2004, 05:05 PM
bones's Avatar
bones bones is offline
Contributor
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 82
bones is on a distinguished road
Credits: 577
Default f

the middle class are really screwed by this. the poor get lots of help, the rich dont need it, but the middle class have to pay large sums out of their own pockets. luckily in florida i can get the bright futures' scholarship and have it all paid for. Thank God.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off
Forum Jump

Sponsored Links

All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:03 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0
Template-Modifikationen durch TMS
vBCredits v1.3 ©2007 by Darkwaltz4
Advertisement System V2.1 By   Branden