This doesn't have to be just about food. One of my favorite sandwiches is bacon, egg and peanut butter on toast. Most people say ewww, all who have tried it love it. Do you have something out of the ordinary that you think we should try?
Peanut butter goes with a lot of things. I've had peanut butter jelly, fried egg and bacon sandwich. That was good. It is strictly a camping sandwich though
Since Elvis and I were born in the same year one of my favorite sandwiches was his favorite: peanut butter, bacon and banana.
Seems to me that you are lacking sources of protein on your toast - perhaps fry up your sandwich in a protein muscle shake...?
Eggnog in coffee. Roughly 1:4 ratio. Though, if you like it as much as I do, coffee will forever be ruined February through October... You've been warned.
That comes after, I mix a protein powder with texas super food in almond milk. It's a little pricey but I really like the super food results.
Peanut butter and sweet pickle sandwiches. Sweet pickles aren't a whole lot different than jelly but it is not quite as sloppy.
Dip potato chips (Ruffles work best) into Sloppy Joe's. Have you ever had fried Lumpia or beef Salpicau? Combine them in one dish and enjoy.