Could Rabbi Alon Anava be more like Rabbi Yeshua - Jesus than any Christian on earth?

LOLOL

Should I start 1400 years ago, and march through the centuries.

 

This is obviously false.

Syria, Lebanon, and other places have had a mixture of religions for long periods of time.

And, when problems do arise, one still has to be careful about jumping to conclusions on what the cause might be.

 

That has nothing to do with what we are talking about.

 

Again, I see that as taking FAR too long, as it means we have to discuss the history of each event and come to conclusions about what brought it about, what ended it (if it ended), etc., etc.

You can get all upset at Catholicism because of the IRA terrorism against England, for example.

But, that doesn't mean we should be taking action against Catholicism - or the Irish, for that matter.

And, the fact of long histories of the various Catholic inquisitions doesn't change that in any way.

 

Most religions have had their share of insanity.

It's just that Islam never grew up, and cannot.
Islam cannot change, to attempt is apostacy.


Oh, yeah, those damn catholic suicide bombers are nuts.

 

Ooops - you didn't notice that comment of mine was addressed to someone else.

 

sorry

 

There is a strong Catholic v Protestant underpinning.

And, what was at the root had to do with home rule, independence, representation - things WE care about, too!

I'm not disputing that connecting religion to political positions happens and tends to be a real problem.

 

I made another thread you might like. in Religion.
It classifies Islam as a political ideology, as opposed to a religion.

 

Change is incredibly difficult for religion. That's not specific to Islam. Look at how many protestant denominations there are!

There were many terrorist acts of bombing over a long period of time.

And, the issues were not even slightly as serious as they are for those who are actually blowing themselves up.

Remember that OBL got suicide bombers by recruiting in relocation camps that hold large numbers of Palestinians who have no hope, no way out, who watch their children starve. That's not what was going on in Ireland. In Ireland, people had hard times and injustice, but they had reason to maintain hope.

 

I was born and raised as a protestant, and never heard of a suicide bombing, or any other crime that could be traced to the religion.

 

We have an average of 6 muslim terror attacks happening every day.
No other religion does that.

 

You have to do more than simply blame the local religion.

And again, the fact that Irish Catholics, Mandela, the ETA and the many various other groups didn't die in the attacks from their groups isn't really that meaningful.

 

LOLOL

70% of the terror attacks are Sunni Muslim
10% are Shia Muslim
Hindu is next.

And there is 10 to 15% that is a total of everyone else on the friggin planet.

 

Again, you have to do more than blame the local religion.

There were times during the "troubles" when the majority of the bombings were done by Catholics.

 

Bullsh-t
The Catholics overran Europe a long time ago, but not on the written orders from the religion.
The Muslims act on the written orders of the religion.

Big difference.

 

You haven't heard of the Holy Roman Empire??? Are you aware of the various inquisitions they held?

But, I was referring to the "troubles" - Catholic Irish v. England.

Sunni Islam (the vast majority) doesn't have anyone who could give such orders. It's not centralized as is Shia Islam (with its Ayatollahs in Iran) or Catholicism (with its Pope).

 

LOLOLOL

Dude.

The written orders in the Qur'an and Sunnah give the orders.
and Yes, you have lots of clerics, Iman, etc, who follow them.

Maybe you can show me the Christian writings that order you to rob and kill people.

 

Remember that ISIS is being wiped out by Muslims.

The claims ISIS has made concerning their interpretation of the Qur'an are not accepted by Islam.

Remember that President Abbas of Palestine works closely with the IDF to prevent violence - even though Israel is carrying out ethnic cleansing against his people!!!

 

Bullsh-t

what claims did ISIS make, that is not accepted by Islam.

ISIS is only one of hundreds of groups that use force to follow the teachings of Muhammed.
They just wanted their own Caliphate.
Most, if not all, the Islamic countries are run by their own terror group.

 

You're making sweeping claims that ignore the specifics of what is going on.

If you want to discuss any specific area of conflict, pick one.

 

Sorry, the claims are real, the excuses vary, but
the words and deeds of Muhammed are the cause.

 

You've made at least two broad generalizations in this one post and fail to defend either of them.

 

I have no intention of writing a book about Muhammed.
They are already written.
If you are too lazy to read them, that is up to you.

As I said, you know nothing of the main person in the religion, Muhammed.