Thread: A structured legal analysis of the meaning of UNSC resolution 242

Originally Posted by HBendor

Your interpretations is warped....

This is the place to address the analysis of UNSC 242 and I've provided a very precise legal analysis of it based exactly upon what it states. I've not seen any rebuttal to that based upon the wording of the Resolution itself.

Originally Posted by Shiva_TD

This is the place to address the analysis of UNSC 242 and I've provided a very precise legal analysis of it based exactly upon what it states. I've not seen any rebuttal to that based upon the wording of the Resolution itself.

Read it again... from Territories and not from THE Territories,,,

Originally Posted by HBendor

Read it again... from Territories and not from THE Territories,,,

Read it again ... "For guaranteeing freedom of navigation through international waterways in the area" not the International waterways. According to you logic this means that Egypt could pick and choose WHICH international waterways to allow Isreal freedom of navigation to; it need not allow access to all of the waterways.

Yeah, right!! Bullcrap reasoning, right?
Same for "THE territories" in that case; same semantics, not so HBendor?

Originally Posted by Shiva_TD

This is the place to address the analysis of UNSC 242 and I've provided a very precise legal analysis of it based exactly upon what it states. I've not seen any rebuttal to that based upon the wording of the Resolution itself.

And for the record, that conclusion of yours still stands, Shiva, despite all the attempted strawman deflections.

Originally Posted by HBendor

Read it again... from Territories and not from THE Territories,,,

Read it again, "Emphasizing the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war"

No territory can be acquired by an act of war which means ALL of the territory occupied by the Israeli military in 1967 is excluded from acquisition by Israel.

Also read the Geneva Conventions again where it states, "The occupying power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own population into the territories it occupies."

The Geneva Conventions prohibit the settlement of those territories occupied by the Israeli military in 1967 by the civilian population of Israel.