The Inevitability of Authoritarian Right Politics
Putting aside what is desirable for a moment, consider the possibility that strong government social authority and a firm economic hierarchy are inevitable- that they are a major and perhaps the final step in our political and cultural evolution. If you are familiar with the political compass, then you will have no difficulty in following my case. Let us consider libertarian leftism, which consists of less government authority and less economic inequality. That is what liberals and most socialists support. It is an impossibility. Humans, being so-often driven by selfishness and a fear of want, hoard what we consider to be ours and so we are all instinctively "right-wing" on economic issues. Some Marxists therefore support temporary social authority to guarantee economic equality. They would be in the authoritarian left quadrant. Their ideas are doomed to fail because with government social authority comes the power of the government to hoard wealth for itself. In that way, libertarian leftists who attempt to move up on the compass to defeat the right will end up supporting a government that is, in reality, in the authoritarian right quadrant (e.g. China). Then there is the libertarian right quadrant, which has no major world leaders in it at present. While it would appeal to our inherent economic selfishness and fear, it is not sustainable either because, just as people hoard wealth (a form of power) out of innate insecurity, they seek social authority in the same way, and strict division of economic classes is only one reflection of the societal struggle for power that leads to a strict hierarchy in all areas of our lives. Therefore, a libertarian right government would, in time, move up on the compass as well. This up and rightward movement is checked by the potential for extreme economic discontent and the anarchic backlash that results from extreme social authority. Therefore, a century from now, I see most governments, including ours, being center-right on economics but very authoritarian (though not to the point of fascism). I will not judge whether this is good or bad, but I think it is an unstoppable movement in governments around the world. I appreciate all replies. Thank you very much.
|