Quote:
Originally Posted by mpotter";p="
Quote:
Originally Posted by DanM";p="
Quote:
Originally Posted by mpotter";p="
Basically what you are saying is that you want a black candidate who acts "white". Someone who doesn't force people to see the issues that the minorities are faced with everyday. Someone who continues to basically hold down the minorities. I have heard it stated several times by black people that they dislike powell and condi because they don't represent the black community well. Many blacks feel that powell and condi are part of "them" meaning the white leaders of our nation who could give a rats ass about them. What we really need is a black leader who is a mix between Al Sharpton and Colin Powell. Someone who is a wonderful mind and voice, and cares about issues on both sides white and black. Someone who isn't all about pleasing one demographic, but rather all demographics. But if you ask me, I think we have needed a president period who has this quality. The closest we came to this was Clinton, the farthest we've come is Bush Jr.
|
If you want to get the votes of all the people, then you have to do more than represent the black community. You have to represent the larger community. Powell does that and Sharpton does not. You show me one position Powell as taken that "keeps the minorities down" and I will not take your earlier statement above as an uninformed, knee jerk slander on a man you do not know.
|
All I said was that white leaders of today don't help the situation at all and in turn "keep the minorities down" by not addressing the issues. I never said that Powell as an individual is keeping the minorities down, and I'm not the one who feels he doesn't represent the black community well. I took that from several other black posters in this forum and from friends of mine who are black. People don't feel he really cares about the true minorities which are not only black but more specifically the poor blacks. I agree that you have to represent more than this, that is what I was trying to say, but you somehow didn't grasp that. This so-called slander was not even mentioned. Others seemed to get my point, but you decided to twist my words around. I've boldfaced words I'd like you to re-read.
|
You said, "Basically what you are saying is that you want a black candidate who acts "white". Someone who doesn't force people to see the issues that the minorities are faced with everyday. Someone who continues to basically hold down the minorities"
So you tell me I want a black candidate who will act white and hold down minorities because I support Collin Powell. Its right there in black and white. That is not even close to summarizing what I said. I said you cannot win a general election by giving preference to the black community to the point where other groups feel excluded by the candidate.
I didn't twist anything you said around. You twisted my comments around, but thats not what bothers me. What bothers me is your comments about Powell trying to keep minorities down.
Give me one example of his policy or one example of a stated belief of his that would hold down minorities. Can you do it or is this criticism of Powell based in something other than a knowledge of the man's views?