Disparity of Military Justice?

longknife · Sep 28, 2014

Marine Corporal Wassef Hassoun faces a general courts-martial for desertion.

And US Army Sergeant Bergdahl? Nothing yet!

Could it possibly have anything to do with the political circumstances of Bergdahl's release versus the way Hassoun showed up?

Nah! Our commander-in-chief would never let anything like that happen.

Would he?

Read more @ http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...tml?ITO=1490&ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490

Imnotreallyhere · Sep 30, 2014

Or possibly the fact that Bergdahl was actually held prisoner rather than wandering around Lebanon for nine years or so? He was arrested there in 2005 by Lebanese cops.

longknife · Oct 1, 2014

Imnotreallyhere said: ↑

Or possibly the fact that Bergdahl was actually held prisoner rather than wandering around Lebanon for nine years or so? He was arrested there in 2005 by Lebanese cops.
Click to expand...

That he was "held captive" is still under investigation.

That he unlawfully walked away from his place of duty in a combat zone is not yet proven but clearly the case if those serving with him are to be believed.

Split hairs all you want. There is still a great disparity here.

Imnotreallyhere · Oct 1, 2014

If the investigation is taking this long, perhaps Bergdahl is telling the truth. Surely if the evidence were as damning as the evidence against Hassoun, Bergdahl would have been charged already.

Hassoun went on leave to Utah and never came back. He was arrested the following year by Lebanese cops, but Lebanon declined to extradite him. He is clearly a deserter.

waltky · Nov 2, 2017

Granny says, "Dat's right - he's nuts - so what?...

Psychiatrist: Bergdahl Mental Disorder Factored in Desertion
1 Nov 2017 | Dr. Charles Morgan said the soldier was already suffering from a schizophrenia-like disorder and PTSD.

Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl's difficult childhood and washout from Coast Guard boot camp stoked serious psychiatric disorders that helped spur him to walk off his remote post in Afghanistan in 2009, a psychiatrist testified Wednesday. Dr. Charles Morgan, called as a defense witness at Bergdahl's sentencing hearing, said the soldier was already suffering from a schizophrenia-like disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder when he disappeared in Afghanistan. Morgan, a forensic psychiatrist and defense consultant, said interviews with family and friends from Bergdahl's childhood, as well as a lengthy exam with Bergdahl, convinced him the soldier was suffering from schizotypal personality disorder when he disappeared in Afghanistan. He said his findings were consistent with a brief Army Sanity Board document that previously made the diagnosis public.

On the stand, Morgan went into much greater detail than what was previously disclosed about Bergdahl's mental health. He said Bergdahl has an internal, self-critical commentary that he doesn't recognize as his own thoughts. He also said he engages in fantasy and has thoughts of self-castration to purify himself. Bergdahl and others with the disorder "have this experience of their own inner life as if it's not them," Morgan said. He said the internal commentary manifests in thoughts such as: "You're never going to be good enough." However, Morgan said the commentary isn't an auditory hallucination, and Bergdahl isn't psychotic. He said Bergdahl knew right from wrong when he walked off his post. Still, the disorder makes it difficult for Bergdahl to see the second- and third-order effects of his actions and how they will impact other people, Morgan said.

Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, left, leaves the Fort Bragg courtroom facility after a sentencing hearing on Oct. 31, 2017, on Fort Bragg, N.C.

Morgan believes Bergdahl had post-traumatic stress disorder even before he enlisted in the Army in 2008 because of his childhood with a quick-tempered father. Symptoms of anxiety and tunnel vision, sometimes present when he interacted with his father growing up, occurred the night Bergdahl had a 2006 panic attack at Coast Guard boot camp that caused him to be discharged, Morgan said. Bergdahl's father believed in corporal punishment and punched holes in the walls when he was angry, Morgan said. Growing up, Bergdahl would sometimes hide when he heard the sound of his father's truck pulling up to their house in Idaho. Bergdahl has said he walked off his remote post in Afghanistan in 2009 without authorization intending to reach another base and describe what he saw as problems with his unit to another commander. Morgan testified that kind of action was consistent with the schizotypal personality disorder diagnosis. "I think he believes there are times if it's the morally right thing to do, you have to break the rules," he said. "There's not a thinking through of: 'Are there other ways to achieve this goal?'"

Since the defense began its sentencing arguments, Bergdahl has taken the stand to apologize to the troops who were wounded in the search for him. And two military agents who debriefed Bergdahl testified Tuesday about how much valuable intelligence he provided when he was returned in a prisoner swap. Prosecutors presented evidence that the wounds to the troops who searched for him merit stiff punishment. Bergdahl faces up to life in prison. The military judge hearing the case has wide discretion on his punishment because Bergdahl didn't strike a plea agreement with prosecutors when he admitted to desertion and misbehavior before the enemy. Morgan was scheduled to be questioned by prosecutors Wednesday afternoon. Closing arguments are expected later this week.

On Monday, Bergdahl began the defense's sentencing presentation by taking the stand to apologize to those wounded searching for him. He also described the brutal conditions he faced in five years of captivity by Taliban allies, including beatings with copper wire and unending bouts of gastrointestinal problems brought on by squalid conditions. He said he was kept in a cage for four of years in captivity after several escape attempts. He said his muscles became so weak he could barely stand or walk. The 31-year-old soldier from Hailey, Idaho, was brought home by President Barack Obama in 2014 in a swap for five Taliban prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. Obama said at the time the U.S. does not leave its service members on the battlefield. Republicans roundly criticized Obama, and Donald Trump went further while campaigning for president, repeatedly calling Bergdahl a "dirty, rotten traitor" who deserved to be executed by firing squad or thrown out of a plane without a parachute.

https://www.military.com/daily-news...gdahl-mental-disorder-factored-desertion.html
Click to expand...

See also:

Agents: Bergdahl Debriefs Were Intelligence 'Gold Mine'
31 Oct 2017 — Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl was a "gold mine" of intelligence, helping the military better understand insurgents and how they imprison hostages, two agents testified Tuesday as defense attorneys sought to show the soldier's contributions since he was returned in a prisoner swap.

The testimony at Bergdahl's sentencing was meant to counter prosecution evidence favoring stiff punishment, including several service members who testified about wounds they suffered on search missions after Bergdahl's 2009 disappearance. Bergdahl faces up to life in prison after pleading guilty to desertion and misbehavior before the enemy for walking off his remote post in Afghanistan in 2009. The Army judge has wide leeway to decide Bergdahl's sentence because he didn't strike a plea agreement with prosecutors. Amber Dach, who spent 16 years in military intelligence, was the primary analyst assigned to Bergdahl's case for the five years after he disappeared. She described how eager he was to help intelligence officials at a hospital in Germany days after he was returned to U.S. authorities. Though his voice was weak and raspy, he helped authorities and even drew diagrams in his downtime to bring to his next debriefing session.

Dach and another official who debriefed Bergdahl both testified that his time in Germany was extended partly so he could offer additional time-sensitive intelligence. "He was very motivated to just download all of the details that he recalled," she testified. "It was a gold mine. It really reshaped the way we did intel collection in the area." An official from the military agency that helps reintegrate former captives and develops survival training for service members testified that information Bergdahl provided him was invaluable. Terrence Russell, a division chief for the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency, developed a 1,200-page transcript from debriefing Bergdahl that was turned into a database. The information produced reports on tactics used by insurgents and hostage-takers in the region that are still used by the military.

Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl arrives at the Fort Bragg courtroom facility for a sentencing hearing on Tuesday, Oct. 31, 2017, on Fort Bragg, N.C.

Russell said he'd like to learn even more from Bergdahl but the soldier's legal case has impeded that. "Can you give him to me tomorrow? I need him. I need him now," he said to a defense attorney. "The fact that I can't get that information is wrong. I need that." He said he'd like to add Bergdahl to a roster of about 30 service members taken captive in recent conflicts dating to the Gulf War who can provide videos or lectures for military survival training. "We don't have very many examples coming out of Afghanistan," he said. He also reaffirmed his previous statements that Bergdahl's captivity was worse than any American prisoner of war has experienced since the Vietnam era.

On Monday, Bergdahl began the defense presentation by apologizing to those wounded searching for him. He also described the brutal conditions he faced, including beatings with copper wire and unending bouts of gastrointestinal problems brought on by squalid conditions. He said he was kept in a cage for four out of the five years in captivity after several escape attempts. He said his muscles became so weak he could barely stand or walk. Russell, who's debriefed more than 100 former hostages and prisoners of war, said Bergdahl's time in the cage was damaging psychologically because he was kept in isolation nearly the entire time. "They simply shut the door. Long-term isolation. Psychological abuse," he said. "It was extreme neglect. They just let him nearly rot inside that cage for four years." The defense showed the court images of a replica of the cage that Russell's agency built, using Bergdahl's sketches. Russell uses it for survival training.

The 31-year-old soldier from Hailey, Idaho, was brought home by President Barack Obama in 2014 in a swap for five Taliban prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. Obama said at the time the U.S. does not leave its service members on the battlefield. Republicans roundly criticized Obama, and Donald Trump went further while campaigning for president, repeatedly calling Bergdahl a "dirty, rotten traitor" who deserved to be executed by firing squad or thrown out of a plane without a parachute. Bergdahl's sentencing hearing is expected to last several more days.

https://www.military.com/daily-news...ahl-debriefs-were-intelligence-gold-mine.html
Click to expand...

yiostheoy · Nov 2, 2017

http://komonews.com/news/nation-wor...ilty-to-desertion-sentencing-set-for-late-oct

Log in or Sign up

Disparity of Military Justice?

longknife New Member

Imnotreallyhere Well-Known Member Donor

longknife New Member

Imnotreallyhere Well-Known Member Donor

waltky Well-Known Member

yiostheoy Well-Known Member

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

Disparity of Military Justice?

longknife New Member

Imnotreallyhere Well-Known Member Donor

longknife New Member

Imnotreallyhere Well-Known Member Donor

waltky Well-Known Member

yiostheoy Well-Known Member

Share This Page

Useful Searches