If they refuse to take the gum out and become belligerent and ratchet the situation to that level......yes. All the student had to do was say "yes ma'am" and be done with it.
That was the comment you were responding to and you wrote a long winded nonsense post trying to justify it. - - - Updated - - - No, sorry. This was in a school with a minor on a phone. Whats the threat ? What is the crime ?
All the administration had to do was suspend or expel the girl for not following the required rules and notify her parents. But that's the sane way to handle students.
Disruption of the school, failure to comply with the lawful order of a police officer, one she refused the orders of the school administrators to vacate the classroom and the hall and go to the office she was trespassing. If students refuse to comply with the instructions of those who have parental authority over them as do the school administrators then what? Mayhem?
And when she refused to comply with their instructions to go to the office to face that suspension and refused to hand over the phone as the school rules require which I am sure they had to sign agreement.......... All the STUDENT had to do was comply with the school rules and comply with the lawful instructions given to her.............you seem to believe different. And BTW the parents apparently were not being supportive of the school.
Ummmm Ray Rice lost his job and most likely his career for knocking out a woman who is bigger than him and attacked him first. Why dot the same rules apply for cops who kneels on a 70lbs. Little girls head over a (*)(*)(*)(*)ing cellphone? Really????? Yeah I'm sorry but if that was my daughter id be in jail for returning the favor on as many as those pigs as possible. I'm sorry, I'm inclined to take an officers side more often than not, but this time I hope those involved slip and crack their head open on the sidewalk.
A moronic comparison, making a mountain out of a mole hill. When you go off the deep end you lose credibility in any debate.
..... responsible for raising a POS child. The fault would be yours. She didn't get this attitude out of nowhere. Neither did Trayvon Martin or Michael Brown.
None of the soft headed leftist get it. Rule of law starts early, like toddler early. Fail to instill it and all of society will pay. .
That's funny, cause I think Cops tackling a girl because she doesn't want to hand over her own property to someone else, an action which is 100% in no way law breaking, is making a mountain out of a mole hill. The idea that you should do what ever you are told to do by people in authority is ridiculous and it's talk like that that leads students to complying with a strip search over Tylenol because they are told to do whatever a person in authority tells them to do. Example: https://www.aclu.org/drug-law-reform/us-supreme-court-declares-strip-search-13-year-old-student-unconstitutional
Back in our day, we usually didn't have to worry about guns and knives in purses and backpacks either. Hell, if we got in a fight we settled it with fisticuffs. Not so now.
Contact their guardian. You know, sane things. What did they accomplish besides escalating the situation into a physical altercation?
Which is what happens when you introduce radical progressivism to a society steeped in individualism. A total breakdown of morality, responsibility and common sense.
Not in a school setting with children. Children given the authority to judge any command issued by the adults in charge, would lead to a lot of bad judgments.
I wouldn't be surprised if the police put her to the ground and cuffed her to end the physical altercation she started.
And their decision to follow or not follow should be met with administrative discipline actions, not physical altercations and arrest which only serve to escalate a minor situation into now a dangerous situation with serious consequences for the student both legal and as we see physical. However one should not be afraid to question it and questioning it should not be met with being physically restrained by law enforcement.
Except no ones account of the incident has even hinted that the girl in anyway initiated any physical contact with anyone.
Do people even read the links before posting? She was not irate, she was not violent. She was on the phone with her mother who was in the hospital. The Ass. Principal asked Ixel to hand over her phone, Ixel turned around and walked away, and was surrounded and tackled by 3 cops. Total over-reaction by cops.