Former Pink Floyd frontman sparks fury by comparing Israelis to Nazis

Trivializing the Holocaust does nothing for credibility

 

Oh you haven't given up. Of course when teaching soldiers you need someone with military training. For judging ethics you need someone who is not biased. You will not find that acceptable to anyone even if you desire to treasure in your heart a false view. It will not help you or your country.

It seems so from the posts I am responding to which are the only one's of yours I have seen. You appear to have no knowledge of checking out the reputation of someone before using them so I thought you might get a better idea from your own soldiers. I have studied this so I am aware of what I am speaking about. If you do not trust what your own soldiers say, what reason could you possibly have for supporting a Christian Zionist who supports soldiers who murder in cold blood. I'll be damned if I know.

 

This person is a holocaust denier.

 

You are an unequivocal propagandist, the Lancet study has been thoroughly debunked, the Iraq casualty figure according to the Iraqi Ministry of Health and Iraq Body Count who actually counted the number of people killed rather than implement a methodologically flawed estimate puts the figure closer to 200,000 the majority of which were not killed by coalition forces.

 

Electronic Intifada is not a source from which we can obtain an unbiased opinion of the man, and please provide me a single time in which I have implemented the daily mail as a source....I'll wait.

 

Speaking to a crowd is not the same thing as being a member of their congregation.

Frontpage is not extremist you just don't like them because they tell the truth about Islamic Imperialist atrocities.

Again you don't like UN Watch because they tell the truth about the OIC dominated UNGA.

Yes they absolutely do namely his associations within the British military which show a distinguished record and his membership in the Advancing Human Rights NGO.

 

Why would Hamas lie about civilian casualties in this case when they are well known to use civilian deaths in their propaganda campaign against Israel?

A civilian contractor isn't a member of the US military, a secretary enlisted in the U.S. military is still combatant just as an enlisted member of Hamas who runs propaganda for Hamas is still a member of a recognized paramilitary terrorist organization and thus a valid military target. This would be like saying the guy holding the camera for the Bin Laden videos was a civilian and not a legitimate military target.

Which ordinance would you have preferred be used in this situation?

The simple fact is that the use of human shields by Hamas is the war crime and not the targeting of Hamas.

- - - Updated - - -

Israel uses WP for it's legitimate and legal use as a smokescreen for ground troops and to illuminate the battlefield at night, provide the video evidence of Israel using WP as an offensive incendiary weapon.

 

What in the jumping Jesus Christ on a cracker are you talking about? Are you trying to assert that the U.S. too is perpetrating genocide against it's minority populations?

 

How very sad.

 

Not all concentration camps were extermination camps. Despite that they were surrounded with high walls, barbed wire, armed guards in watch towers...hmm, sounds just like Gaza.

 

Israel didn't create the concentration camps, they were created by the Arab states and the refugee camps are currently governed by the UN, is the UN now akin to Nazi's too?

Oh (*)(*)(*)(*)ing spare me Israel shutting down their own borders because of Hamas suicide bombers does not make Gaza a concentration camp.

Does this look like a (*)(*)(*)(*)ing concentration camp to you:

 

More trivializing of the Holocaust. Very sad indeed.

 

Why did the IRA, bent on the destruction of the British establishment, choose to negotiate? We talked, we have peace after decades of violence, beatings, bombings and murder. The operative is 'peace'. You may have heard of it.

- - - Updated - - -

What is sad is your absurdly ignorant comment. I replied correctly; there were only a few dedicated extermination camps among many concentration camps. Read some history.
You will note in the attached link that Holocaust scholars make a distinction between the two.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_concentration_camps

 

I had no responsibility for any of it, my European ancestors all left Europe by the early 1800s.

I refuse to feel guilt over it.

People need to get over it, what I find sad is people living with an eternal victim complex that fills them with hate for others and leads them to seek to do unto others what was done to them.

 

You have already proven that you are a holocaust denier in this thread and that combined with your praise for the Islamic radical fundamentalist terrorist in the other thread tells the forum everything we need to know about you, I tell you I was absolutely shocked to learn that you're married to a Muslim of Iranian descent, shocked I tell you!

 

"Peace"......it's so simple it's a wonder no one thought of it before. I think a Nobel Prize may be in order here.

 

Iranians are some of the most charming, warm and welcoming people I have met. I worked with many in London during the 1970s. Iranian women are also among the world's most beautiful. But naturally for the terminally ignorant US conservative, every last one is a foaming at the mouth jihadist.

 

Yet somehow you feel endless sympathy for the Palestinians.,,,,so hard to figure out why.

 

Because their goal was never the destruction of England only the independence of Northern Ireland and secular democracy albeit with a socialist bent, Hamas on the other hand considers all of Israel to be occupied territory and an Islamic Waqf.

- - - Updated - - -

I'm not a conservative but I do dislike Islam which I am not hesitant to admit, and her holocaust denial and overt praise for a self confessed Islamic radical terrorist and murderer in the other thread is very telling as to what "charming" information she's getting from her Muslim husband.

[video=youtube;92myDzAFgU4]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92myDzAFgU4[/video]

How charming.

 

The Palestinian cause is the human rights issue of our decade, I was too little to have any involvement with The US Civil Rights Movement. And if I had not been too little, considering the color of my skin and where I lived I would have probably been on the wrong side too.

But so many similarities there are between the Pre Civil Rights Movement South and Apartheid Israel and her treatment of Palestinians.

I see it as a Blessing to be a part of this international movement committed to seeing Palestine free from Occupation.

That documentary The Freedom Riders showed the bus of activists pulling into a location in the South and a crowd started attacking them. And there were women with babies legs wrapped around their waists screaming hate. Flash forward, to the illegal settlements in the Occupied West Bank and there entire communities, with mothers with their babies legs wrapped around their waists, congregate at junctions and encourage their children to throw rocks at passing Palestinian cars, screaming hate. The images so much the same, even as thousands of miles and decades of time separate the incidents from one another

Silence in the face of Injustice is complicity with it, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr wrote that in a jail cell in the South. He watched the white Churches in the South turn a blind eye to the Injustices of Segregation.

You know what, we all.have a choice as to how we respond to Injustices we live amidst. Are we silent in the face of them? Do we take stands against them? Do we choose to care about those suffering Injustices? Every day is filled with so many choices.

 

Yes, I agree with you here. AlJazeera had a program recently about young American Jews coming to this decision - some actively devoting their lives to trying to help the Palestinians because such a feeling of protecting those oppressed was the basis of the morality they had been brought up with.

 

Since there are no fences around the camps in Israel, we know you are just making the (*)(*)(*)(*) up as you go along.

 

Except, unlike the Palestinains with their stated goal of the elimination of Israel and the Jews from Israel, the Black Americans and South Africans had no such goals.

 

Celebrity dilettantes on acid are apparently the inspiration for all kinds of superficial equivalencies.

 

That was Syd Barrett.